Here's my verdict for anyone who is interested:
1) I was disappointed by the emphasis put on hunting particularly in the first half of the programme. Hunting is a part of countrylife, but it rather gave the impression that it WAS countrylife.
2) I don't think the voice-over really got to the heart of the problems facing dairy farmers. When they were shooting the calfs they weren't really explaining why. The documentary maker has said in interviews that farmers have been put in the position they have because of the way people eat and shop - but the programme didn't show people why that is the case.
3) I wish there had been much more like the bit with the agent filling in the SFP form - I think that really showed what farmers are up against in terms of regulation.
4) I was fairly uncomfortable about the way they were pushing on the gate when trying to load the cattle onto the lorry. One had its leg on the other side and it didn't look good...
5) The smallholder who said that the countryside had been renationlised on the quiet summed things up pretty well.
It is clear that the documentary maker is sympathetic to the plight of farmers, but I am not sure the end programme will have really helped the cause.
As an example, here is an e-mail I have just been sent:
|
"I watched this programme on the 3rd of may' and the farmer who killed those calf's just because they are not good for meat' was disgraceful. He could have given them to a sanctuary. Then I saw him kill a horse the same way. Then noticed he was a fox hunter/killer which did not surprise me.Just wondered how he would like to be cast aside like that, bye someone as unemotional and as hard faced as him. It was humane the way he killed them but why! I just hope heaven exists and he is greeted bye all those helpless animals. I think looking at that man who killed those baby calf's he is just a trigger happy killer of defenceless animals. ( A COWARD) bet he got bullied at school. And no I'm not a vegetarian'' I just have feelings." |