Approved fungicides shine in HGCA wheat trials

Two recently approved BASF fungicides, Ennobe and Brutus, have topped the HGCA’s appropriate fungicide dose trials for efficacy against Septoria tritici, growers and advisers heard at the first HGCA cereal disease roadshow.

Ennobe, a mix of epoxiconazole and prochloraz, and Brutus, a combination of epoxiconazole and metconazole, both offered growers the chance to use products with a very heavy loading of azole fungicide, Jonathan Blake of ADAS said.

At its full dose of 1.8 litres/ha Ennobe contained a full dose of prochloraz and a 90% dose of epoxiconazole, while Brutus contained 92% of a full dose of metconazole plus the 90% dose of epoxiconazole, he said.

In the HGCA trials that allowed the products to be clearly better than the single azole fungicide standards of epoxiconazole and prothioconazole in both protecting against septoria and as eradicants, particularly at lower doses.

A lot of that increased efficacy was probably down to the increased azole loading, he suggested. For example, half doses of each product were applying just under the equivalent of a full dose of azole fungicide, and were being compared with a half dose of the single azole products.

But not all of the extra activity could be put down to that loading, he noted. Matching percent septoria infections against units of azole applied showed the new fungicides still performing better than Opus (epoxiconazole). That was a surprise, Mr Blake said. “The formulation is clearly better than the mixture would suggest. They have done something with the formulation that improves performance.”


Ennobe and Brutus offer good control of brown rust and, particularly, septoria in HGCA trials last season, says ADAS’s Jonathan Blake

The trials also confirmed that Proline (prothioconazole) and Opus performed similarly against septoria as in past years.

Yield results from the trials also showed an advantage for Brutus and particularly Ennobe, although Mr Blake suggested growers shouldn’t read too much into Ennobe’s advantage after just one year’s trials.

In the brown rust trial Brutus also gave the best performance, Stuart Knight of The Arable Group said. “It is a step up for brown rust control.” Again, part of that higher efficacy is simply due to the high loading of azole fungicide, but Mr Knight pointed out the half dose of Brutus performed better than a full dose of Opus.

Ennobe wasn’t included in these trials, as it was seen more as a septoria product and because there wasn’t space to include every product, he added.

Proline’s relative weakness against brown rust was again highlighted by the 2008 trial, although the product is similar to Opus against yellow rust, unless the season is very challenging. The addition of fluoxastrobin to prothioconazole in Firefly or Fandango added massively to brown rust control, he noted.


Ask the... Breeder

Register now

Online grain trading made easy with Farmers Weekly Graindex

It takes just a couple of minutes to create a listing on Farmers Weekly Graindex and you’ll get a range of prices to compare from active buyers who want your grain.
Visit Farmers Weekly Graindex
See more