Cereal chain profiting
By Charles Abel
ADDED VALUE supply chains for the cereal sector are a challenge, but commercial examples are being pursued following a two year project financed by the Farmers” Fund*.
“Wheat is the ultimate commodity, so creating added-value cereal supply chains is not easy,” admits project manager Richard Warburton of Bidwells. “But while they won”t solve the problems of the industry, they may create some niches of value to some people.”
Late last year the project consortium, comprising Bidwells, Imperial College and Crop Management Information, staged two seminars to present findings to key players in the UK cereal supply chain.
As expected, scepticism was rife. “But the difficulties people identified may be exactly what make it worth doing. And what”s the alternative for getting more money back to growers from cereal production,” he asks.
The project pinpointed potentially useful traits, their value to the market and what factors influence commercial production.
Plenty of traits were available, many unrecognised by the industry, Mr Warburton notes. The difficulty was finding a market value for them, particularly due to long time lags and the practice of sharing spirit in the distilling sector and the dominant emphasis on cost and volume in the feed industry.
Milling offers more potential, but the current recommended list system, which does little to encourage niche varieties, was seen as a key barrier.
Trading mindsets, favouring short-term, volume and efficiency-driven strategies, also get in the way.
Furthermore, many traits interest consumers, not processors, giving breeders, retailers and branded manufacturers the main claim on added value, not growers.
To get round that growers need to work in well managed, private, closed groups and take some risk in the project, such as investing or even initiating the exercise.
“That”s not desperately easy to do,” Mr Warburton admits. “But where a combination of exclusivity, risk, and technical excellence are combined it ensures that a supply group becomes an essential part of the initiative and the prospect of replacing the farmers in the market becomes inconceivable.”
His preferred mechanism for appropriating value is to work on a retail-price-minus-percentage-margin for each element of the chain. “That way the share of margin is established at the outset and everybody works to maximise revenues.”
Robust legal structures are unlikely initially, so plenty of trust and an acceptance of risk is needed, he notes.
Bidwells and the other project partners are now working with several cereal-based groups to develop specific added-value cereal supply chains. The work complements similar consultancy for fresh produce and livestock, geared to local and regional food in particular. Advice includes training to improve farmer, processor and retailer performance, setting and managing contracts, and defining supplier assessment systems.
