Let farmers vote on quangos
FARMERS NEED a free vote on the future of levy bodies, according to the author of a report which branded the Milk Development Council and British Potato Council as “useless”.
Dan Lewis, a research fellow with the Centre for Policy Studies, said levy payers had been polled on the future of the British Potato Council, but the same should happen with other bodies.
“I believe all compulsory levy-funded bodies are unacceptable in a democracy,” he said.
“I think it is unacceptable to have a levy without the balloted agreement of a majority of the producers. This is taxation without representation.”
Mr Lewis was commenting after publication of his report The Essential Guide to British Quangos 2005 on Fri (Feb 11).
The report questioned the existence of Britain‘s 529 quangos or non-departmental public bodies.
The BPC, MDC and Agricultural Wages Boards were among the nine most useless, it added.
But the bodies concerned have questioned the criteria by which they were judged.
Amy Jackson, head of communications at the MDC, said: “We don‘t know the criteria by which MDC has been graded.
“But we do know we work to improve profitability for producers by acting on prices, costs and market transparency.”
Helen Priestley, chief executive of the BPC, believed the report was flawed “through deliberate misrepresentation or through lack of research”.
“The author‘s main suggestion is that the BPC should end because consumers wouldn‘t miss it.
“In fact, the BPC is funded by the potato industry and it is the industry that must see the main benefit, albeit that meeting consumer needs is the key to future success,” she said.
*For more detail on why representatives from the BPC, MDC and the AWB believe their organisations are useful to farmers see FARMERS WEEKLY on Fri (Feb 18).

