Timing’s the key to achieve effective sclerotinia control
IT IS the annual conundrum for oilseed rape growers: Is it worth spraying for sclerotinia?
The risk is difficult to predict for individual crops, admits ADAS oilseed rape expert Peter Gladders. “There”s an insurance argument for spraying, but, as the disease infects a wide range of crops, control may benefit the whole rotation.”
Incidence of the disease can differ regionally. “In recent years, crops in the north have been hit harder. But there are hotspots in the West Midlands, east and south east.”
Tighter rotations will also increase the disease threat, he predicts. “But it is the weather that has the biggest influence on disease development. If it is unsettled at flowering, infected petals tend to stick to the leaves and stems of the oilseed rape plant, allowing the fungus to infect the plant.”
For this reason spray timing is more important than product choice, he says. “The fungus gets into the plant within 24 hours. It has such a short latent period that you can”t exploit the curative activity of fungicides. So they have to be applied before the infection event.”
Where crops are judged to be at risk, aim to treat them before mid-flowering, which is when petals start to fall in large numbers. “A good guideline is when 20 flowers have opened on the main raceme. Wheeling damage is reduced considerably by spraying at this stage, rather than at the end of flowering.”
Half-rate treatments work well if the timing is right, but also consider the threat from other diseases, he says. “Alternaria [for which the timing, ideally, is later] may be an issue if winter sprays for light leaf spot and phoma were not used. To protect pods after flowering, rates must be kept up.”
Physiological effects as well as disease control are claimed for BASF”s Filan (boscalid), as well as for this year”s newcomers, Amistar (azoxystrobin) and Proline (prothioconazole), he notes. “In trials, they have all performed very well. Growers can expect 90% control if they pay attention to timing.”
Using Proline will help with seed retention, as well as giving good control of sclerotinia, says Bayer CropScience”s Alison Daniels. “There is a crop greening effect, which delays senescence and seems to reduce pod shatter. We are not sure of the mechanism yet, but the results have been impressive.”
German trials showed where harvest was delayed due to rain there was a 0.5t/ha yield benefit in Proline-treated crops. “Other fungicides only gave a 0.15t/ha increase.”
Proline can be used at rates of 0.35-0.5 litres/ha, she adds. “That”s 10-15/ha cheaper than either Amistar or Filan at an average rate.”
Proline”s broad-spectrum of activity is a further bonus, she believes. “If you”ve got light leaf spot still festering in the crop, you will need a triazole component at this timing and it also offers activity against alternaria.”
Syngenta trials with Amistar show an average yield response of 0.4t/ha, says the firm”s technical manager Beth Hall. “The results have been very consistent, whether it was a low, moderate or high disease pressure season. It seems as though physiological effects are the reason for this.”
Like Amistar, Filan also offers yield responses in the absence of disease. “In trials that is around 0.2t/ha, which rises to 0.5t/ha when there is disease to control,” says BASF”s Diane Heath.
Rate is important, she adds. “If you use lower than the 0.5kg/ha rate you lose the physiological benefits.”
