CAP reform hits organic farmers

HUNDREDS OF pioneering organic farmers, and all organic dairy farmers, will be disadvantaged as a result of new CAP payments, the Soil Association has said.


It is warning that up to 200 longstanding organic farmers, as well as 600 organic dairy farmers who have converted more recently, will not receive the same level of payments as other farmers and will be denied access to compensation.


Organic farmers who were disadvantaged subsidy-wise because they were part of an agri-environment scheme between 1997 and 2002 can apply for a representative reference amount calculated or to have their reference period changed.


But farmers who converted to organic production before 1994 – when organic grant aid first became available – will have no such option.


DEFRA has told the association that these farmers should not expect to get compensated for the “business decision” they made when they went organic.


A spokesman told FW that these farmers now benefited from their head start in producing for the market rather than for subsidies.


The association, however, argues that these longstanding organic farmers could not possibly foresee at the time that they would be disadvantaged 11 years later in terms of CAP payments.


It has called upon DEFRA, SEERAD and the Welsh Assembly to address this issue by releasing funds from the National Reserve.


SA director Patrick Holden said: “DEFRA‘s decision is grossly unfair. These farmers pioneered sustainable agriculture and have provided environmental benefits for over 10 years. They never benefited from public money to convert to organic farming, and now they will lose out yet again.”


“Accommodating these farmers would not involve significant sums of public money; it is the principle that is important,” Mr Holden said.


He added that the situation is particularly serious for organic farmers in Wales and Scotland, as they can not expect to see a more equitable, area-based payment come in over time as will be the case in England.


As for dairy producers, they will receive a payment based on the amount of milk quota held on Mar 31, 2005.


But since organic dairy farmers for a number of reasons – the breeds and forage they use, as well as their lower stocking densities – usually produce less milk than non-organic dairy farmers, the SA is concerned about their CAP outcome.


The DEFRA spokesman pointed out, however, that under the new stewardship schemes soon to come into effect there is an organic strand of £60 extra per hectare so that the new arrangements as a whole are not to the disadvantage of the organic sector.

See more