Newcomers mean subsidies face cuts

SINGLE FARM payments will have to be cut by about 10% to accommodate Romania and Bulgaria into the EU, unless the financial ceilings agreed in 2002 are raised.


Negotiations on the new budget for 2007-2013 are already under way and the EU presidency is keen to wrap up an agreement by July, Austrian head of agriculture in Brussels, Verena-Maria Hagg, told this week”s Agra-Europe Outlook conference.


But it was still far from clear whether extra funds would be available to make direct payments to farmers in the two east European countries, or whether the existing pot would have to be raided.


“Our calculations show that, if Romania and Bulgaria have to fit within the Brussels ceiling, we would need a degressivity rate approaching a two-digit figure,” she said. Such aid cuts would be targeted at farmers in the old EU-15, as the 10 new member states are exempt from such cuts.


Ms Hagg added that it was too soon to work out what SFP cuts might arise from this year”s sugar reform. That would depend on the scale of any price and quota reductions and the amount of compensation agreed.


DEFRA head of sustainable farming Andy Lebrecht also warned of future cuts to SFPs, as UK taxpayers questioned whether the “public goods” they were getting from farmers were worth the 1.7bn a year it was costing them.


“One”s instinct suggests that is probably rather generous,” he said. “You”d probably get rather better value for money by targeting the money through the second pillar (of rural development measures).”


Chief agriculture adviser at the EU commission, Claus Sorensen, agreed that rural development policy was the way forward in terms of delivering competitive rural communities with strong growth.


philip.clarke@rbi.co.uk

See more