Your questions answered

Welcome to our free reader enquiry service.


If you have a question on a legal, planning, tax, or business rates subject you’d like answered, then get in touch.


We can only answer a proportion of the queries received but if it’s a subject of potential interest to other readers, our panel of accountants, solicitors, tax experts and planning advisers will get cracking on it and we’ll print the answers in FARMERS WEEKLY.


Email your questions to fwreaderqueries@rbi.co.uk or fax them to 020 8652 4005 or write to FARMERS WEEKLY Legal Queries, Quadrant House, The Quadrant, Sutton, Surrey SM2 5AS.


All questions will be published anonymously.


Please give enough detail to allow an accurate answer to be given.


My farm manager lives in a house on the estate.


His marriage is on the rocks.


Can the court order him to leave the house and for his wife to remain in occupation as part of his divorce?


Answered by Oliver Gravell, a partner and head of the family team at Birketts, Ipswich oliver-gravell@birketts.co.uk


Unfortunately, this may happen.


The court has the power to make orders with regards to a couple’s assets.


These can include where they live, if they occupy their home under a “relevant tenancy”.


These include tenancies regulated by the Rent (Agriculture) Act 1976, the Rent Act 1977 and the Housing Act 1988.


However, agricultural tenancies regulated by the Agricultural Holdings Act 1986 and Farm Business Tenancies under the Agricultural Tenancies Act 1995 are not regulated tenancies.


The court can order that a wife and children remain in the house even if the tenancy was granted only to the husband, and even if there are covenants prohibiting re-assignment.


What can you do in these circumstances?


If you become aware that your employee has matrimonial difficulties, you must check to see if the tenancy is a “relevant tenancy”.


If it is not, the court cannot order the transfer of the tenancy to his spouse.


If it is a relevant tenancy, the landlord is entitled to make representations to the court hearing the divorce case, particularly if they want their employee to remain in the property.


Usually, if the landlord informs the court that the tenancy was granted in order that an employee will live on site, the court will not transfer the tenancy away from that employee.


If the situation arises, the landlord should make urgent contact with their employee’s solicitor.


I am proposing to buy a doublecab pickup and have been told by the dealer that I can reclaim the VAT on it.


Is this correct?


Answered by Dave Brown, director of VAT services at Bishop Fleming, Exeter dbrown@bishopfleming.co.uk


This type of vehicle has a chequered history as, until December 1999, they were regarded as cars by the VAT Office and consequently the VAT would not normally be claimable.


After some extended lobbying by the motor trade, amongst others, they eventually conceded that doublecab pickups would be VAT-deductible as commercial vehicles, subject to certain conditions.


The principal condition is that the payload of the vehicle must exceed 1000kg.


In technical terms, this is the difference between the vehicle’s kerb weight and its maximum gross weight, but in practice most manufacturers show the payload in the technical specifications.


One point that you should bear in mind is that fitting a hard top on the rear might reduce the payload to below the critical 1000kg figure, as an average of 45kg must be deducted if such an item is fitted.


If the vehicle has a payload of 1030kg, for instance, deducting 45kg would transform it immediately into a car, at which point the VAT would not be claimable.


A final condition, which is fairly obvious, is that the vehicle must be used principally for business purposes.


If there is more than incidental private use, then not all of the VAT can be reclaimed.


My bank manager has suggested that I consider ceasing farming and just take the single farm payment on my 300-acre farm.


What are the tax implications of this?


Answered by Peter Homent, senior partner, Hardcastle Burton, Royston, Herts peterh@hardcastle-burton.co.uk


The single farm payment will be taxed as trading income.


If no crops are being grown and there is no other business activity then the allowability of household and motoring expenses would be restricted in the light of reasonable business use.


More important is the possible loss of agricultural property relief on the farmhouse.


It has been suggested that if no agricultural activity is taking place other than the compliance issues for SFP then the Revenue will take the view that the farmhouse is not being occupied for the purpose of agriculture.


This is one of the prime tests in considering whether APR applies and we would suggest that until the situation becomes clear at least 50% of the land should be cropped, even if it is by a contractor.


I want to get change of use on my redundant farm buildings to offices and light industry.


The planning officer has been to visit the farm and has said the existing farm access cannot cope with the increased traffic.


I have suggested that a new access comes in off the main road, across my land to the buildings, but he still says consent won’t be granted.


What do I do?


Answered by Barry Davies, Davies and Co, Kettering, Northants bdavies@daviesandco.co.uk


The Planning Officer’s remit is to consider your application for offices and light industry (B1 Use class) under the existing local plan policy, and national government guidance (PPS 7).


I suggest you appoint a surveyor or planning consultant and a highways engineer, who will negotiate with the county highways engineer in regard to your existing farm access servicing the converted farm buildings into light industry/offices use.


If the proposed development is not likely to increase traffic on the adjoining road by more than 5%, then it is very unlikely you will require a new access.


Also, for a farm access off a standard 60mph country road you will need to have 9m back from the road in each direction 215m visibility along the road edges.


There is a direct correlation between the size of the farm buildings for conversion and the increase in traffic flow, as well as the car parking spaces that must be made available.


The planners or county highways engineer may ask for a Traffic Impact Assessment and generally office use generates more traffic than light industry, so be cautious and research your market as to who is going to occupy the buildings.


This is essential prior to the application being submitted.


It is also essential to prepare a schedule of all existing farm traffic, HGVs, tractors, trailers, vans that are coming to and from the farm buildings, in addition to the proposed additional traffic.


I am in a farming partnership with my mother and father.


My father will not allow me to see the partnership bank statements.


What legal right do I have to see them?


Answered by William Barr, a partner in Mills & Reeve and based at the firm’s Cambridge office
william.barr@mills-reeve.com


As with all partnership queries, start by looking at the partnership deed to see whether it covers the issues specifically.


Traditional clauses deal with cheque signing rather than receipt of bank statements, but no partnership query can be conclusively answered without looking at the agreement between the parties.


The next stop may be the bank mandate.


If the mandate signed provides that all partners may have statements, then the bank may give what father will not.


The son should, however, tread carefully on the banking relationship.


Subject to any specific arrangements in the partnership document (most unlikely), or if no written partnership agreement exists, the general position is that information relating to partnership affairs belongs to all partners and should be available to them.


A partner has a legal right to see documents relating to partnership activities and finances while he remains a partner.


Each partner also owes to the other(s) a duty of the utmost good faith.


It is a breach of such duty to refuse access to partnership bank accounts.


This is a situation where the practicalities are far less easy than the legal solution.


If the son was to apply to the court, he would undoubtedly be successful in obtaining an order to see the documents.


That approach would also ensure that the whole partnership could not continue.


Personal relationships would be too severely damaged.


The son is right to be concerned about the bank statements and to be even more concerned when his access is refused.


As a partner he is liable jointly and severally with the other partners for all partnership liabilities and he needs to know what the financial position is.


He also needs to consider what this tells him about his future in the partnership.


If the business is otherwise going well and the son is confident from annual accounts and other information that there are no problems, then he might view this as an eccentricity of his father with which he must live.


The more likely analysis is that refusal to show him partnership bank statements tells him something much more profound.


It may be bad news on the partnership finance front or an indication that he is not being treated as a partner at all.


The son should try to discuss the issue with his father and negotiate with him and any other partners.


If that is not successful then the son should understand that in any commercial partnership, exclusion from financial information is so serious that it will almost inevitably lead to a break up of the partnership.


The son must consider whether the advantages to him in remaining in the partnership make up for the disadvantages and risks he is running.


One of my employees regularly turns up to work very hung over.


He operates machinery and I am worried that there will be an accident.


What should I do?


Answered by James Wilders, a partner at Dickinson Dees, Newcastle. james.wilders@dickinson-dees.com


If your employee’s condition is affecting the quality of his work then he may be in breach of one or more of the terms set out in his written contract of employment.


He may also be in breach of a term implied by law in all employment contracts to provide loyal and efficient service.


In these circumstances you should consider warning the employee about his performance, and notify him that you expect him to attend for work in a fit state to fulfil his duties properly and efficiently.


If the employee persists in turning up for work hung over you can consider issuing a formal warning against him.


As a first step, verify if you have your own disciplinary and grievance procedures.


If so, you should ensure that you follow your own, internal procedures.


You should immediately draw up such procedures if you do not already have them.


An employee has the right to be accompanied by a colleague or trade union representative at a disciplinary hearing.


You should notify him of this in the written notice convening the hearing.


Also, any warning that you issue should be limited in time, and then disregarded once it has expired.


For example, oral warnings and first written warnings frequently apply for six months whereas final written warnings often apply for 12 months.


The next stage warning can be issued if an employee commits an act of misconduct while an earlier warning is still outstanding.


The ultimate sanction against an employee who persists in attending for work so hung over that he is unable to perform his duties is dismissal.


You are obliged as a minimum to follow the statutory dismissal procedure.


This involves issuing a written statement of grounds for action, giving details of the basis for taking action, meeting the employee at a disciplinary hearing to give him an opportunity to answer your complaints, then communicating your decision and at the same time notifying the employee of his right to appeal against your decision.


If the employee has 12 months’ service or longer then he will be entitled to pursue an unfair dismissal claim against you in the Employment Tribunals.


At any hearing, the tribunal would scrutinise, for example, the procedure which you applied, the evidence on which you based your allegations against the employee and his disciplinary record.


If you fail to follow the statutory procedure described above then the dismissal will be automatically unfair.


As regards health and safety, if the employee’s behaviour is a “known risk”, steps must be taken to ensure both his safety, and that of other employees and third parties.


If an accident occurred involving that employee then an employer with knowledge of the risk will be liable.


I farm in one of the National Parks, and am concerned at the number of walkers using the footpath crossing the boundary of my farm.


On several occasions recently I have found the gate across the footpath has been left open and once I was only just in time to prevent 35 Limousin bullocks from straying onto my neighbour’s land, which is arable and not properly fenced.


There is a public highway beyond the arable land.


What is the position if my cattle get onto the road and cause an accident?


Answered by William Green, head of agriculture at Burnetts Solicitors, Carlisle. (01228 552222).


The first and most important thing you can do is ensure you have good public liability insurance, because a recent case found a farmer liable in circumstances similar to those you describe.


He was successfully prosecuted for negligence, partly because his well-maintained gate (new in 1998) did not have a “Please Shut the Gate” sign on it.


The method of securing the gate – a chain and hook – was also thought inadequate in the circumstances.


Given its constant use, the gate should have been fitted with a self-locking mechanism.


The court also suggested that the gate might be secured and an alternative access (such as a stile or kissing gate) provided.


The farmer’s solicitor described all of this as “a counsel of perfection”, and no doubt many farmers would agree.


But the court held to the view that the footpath ran through a National Park, was well used, and this led to higher standards being expected.


I have applied to take up British Sugar’s offer to buy back beet contract tonnage, but have been told that the payments will be treated as income.


Is this correct?


Answered by Jonathan Ellis, Larking Gowen, Norwich. jonathan.ellis@larking-gowen.co.uk


Contrary to expectations, any proceeds from this buy up scheme will be assessable to income tax for individuals and corporation tax for companies, rather than being treated as the disposal of a capital asset for tax purposes.


Furthermore the income cannot be spread over a number of accounting periods


Email your questions to fwreaderqueries@rbi.co.uk

See more