Call to develop calving ease index
WORK ON a new calving ease index for dairy bulls could start next year if DEFRA approves industry proposals in response to rising calf mortality and Interbull requirements for bull proofs.
Calving ease is affected by a sire’s influence on calf size, gestation length and the maternal effect of how easily a bull’s daughter will calve. Producers using easy-calving sires in the past 3-4 years are now experiencing calving problems with offspring, says vet Rob Drysdale of Sussex-based Westpoint Vet Services.
“We’ve assisted many heifer calvings in the last year with apparently biggish calves, but which turned out to be normal. Some dams haven’t been fed correctly to develop frame at the right time,” he says.
But he thinks the main cause is heifers sired by easy-calving bulls having a smaller pelvis. At worst, a difficult calving can lead to a dead heifer. “And in most cases there is damage to the uterus or a trapped nerve which can reduce fertility.”
This is why a breeding index for calving ease is as important as a fertility index, says Holstein UK”s Lucy Andrews. “It will help address some of the issues raised by vets alluding to maternal calving difficulties because as herds get bigger, they need easier management,” she says.
“Quicker genetic progress means breeding replacements from heifers. Having the confidence to breed black-and-white sires onto maiden heifers using a calving ease index willl be a bonus.”
Current figures provided by companies are too crudely measured to make sensible selection decisions, says SAC geneticist Mike Coffey. “We don’t differentiate between a malpresentation – due to random chance – or score caesarians separately.”
Aside from the economic impact on milk production, Dr Coffey stresses calving ease is a welfare issue.
A national index will help breeders and satisfy Interbull’s move to publish international calving ease evaluations, says Genus’ Mark Smith.
“It has a big influence on customers’ buying decisions. Although we collect data on a bull’s suitability for use on heifers, it’s not a predicted transmitting ability and this can be confusing for producers comparing bulls on calving ease.”
With many customers using black- and-white semen on maiden heifers, calving ease is an issue. But many problems can be due to management, says Cogent’s Marco Winters. He recommends not using unproven sires on maiden heifers. “Selecting proven sires based on current calving ease data is still worthwhile.”