Video: Farmers fight for fairer deal on HS2

Landowners have taken their fight for a fair deal on the proposed high speed rail link (HS2) to parliament.

The Country Land and Business Association (CLA) has submitted an 18-point petition to MPs outlining “unaddressed issues that are disadvantaging businesses” along phase one of the HS2 between London and Birmingham.

CLA president Henry Robinson, said that the heart of the petition was fighting for a duty of care for those suffering from the land taken by the project, which was described as excessive earlier this year by landowners.

Those affected by the scheme should be central to any decision-making process, according to Mr Robinson who believed proper communication between HS2 Ltd and landowners would have resulted in less land being taken.

“Many farms, businesses and homes stand to lose vast swathes of land or have land cut in half by the route as HS2 Ltd arbitrarily grabs land to compensate for the project’s environmental impact,” Mr Robinson said.

The petition also calls for the government to ensure the compensation system reflects the total losses incurred and not just a payout at market value.

Mr Robinson explained: “Many buildings will be left unoccupied as a result of the scheme in these cases the landowner should not have to pay empty property rates or council tax.”

One farmer facing compulsory purchase as a result of the HS2 is Robert Davies of Middleton House Farm, Staffordshire. He is featured in a CLA video that focuses on farmers whose businesses could be ruined by the railway line.

Mr Davies said his farm would be cut in two and that he had been left by HS2 Ltd without enough provision to get from one side of the farm to the other.

“Instead of just a 30-second journey it will now be at least 20 minutes with a tractor and trailer. With a combine and dual wheels it will be at least an hour,” Mr Davies said.

The income from a thriving bed and breakfast business will also come to an end as a result of the new rail line, according to Mr Davies.

The second farmer featured by the video, Robert Moulton, of Bucks Head Farm, Staffordshire, has seen his farm hit by two major construction projects in 10 years.

“In 2005 we had the A5 dual carriage-way, which went east to west and took 40 acres [16ha] of land and now the railway will go north to south splitting the farm into four and with 70 acres [28ha] gone. In less than 10 years we have lost a quarter of the farm,” Mr Moulton said.

Watch CLA president Henry Robinson visit farms in Staffordshire affected by the HS2 project.

CLA 18-point petition

  • Duty of care and fair compensation

  • Blight notices – abolish rateable value cap with enforceable timescales

  • Assured Compensation Scheme (alternative scheme to property bond)

  • Permanent land take – impact on agriculture – should be minimum

  • Temporary land take – should be by lease and returned to landowner

  • Severance and accommodation works

  • Period of notice for procession should be lengthened depending on the needs of the business

  • Payment of compensation in advance of entry

  • Remove upper limits for loss payments

  • Compensation in respect of minerals

  • Remove ability for HS2 to compulsory purchase for regeneration

  • Special provisions where borrowing exceeds market value

  • Compensation for additional long term losses

  • Exemption from empty business rates/council tax

  • Voluntary schemes – need to be applicable to all

  • Increase in statutory rate of interest to a commercial rate

  • Payment of fees for business advice

  • Indefinite roll-over or exemption from capital gains tax


Farmers Weekly Awards Show

Join us for a week-long extravaganza to celebrate the farming heroes and achievements of 2020 and announce the winners of the Farmers Weekly Awards. Countryfile presenter Adam Henson will host five nights of entertainment in 20-minute programmes filmed all over the country. He'll be joined by a host of farming celebrities and feature a special appearance by HRH Prince Charles.
Find out more
See more