Lords wary of effects of UK:EU dynamic alignment
© Adobe Stock With the UK:EU summit scheduled for this Friday (20 November), a House of Lords committee has reiterated the risks of realigning food standards without a viable transition period and proper parliamentary scrutiny.
According to Lord Stirrup, who chairs the European Affairs committee, implementing the planned sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement for food and farming alone would generate at least 780 pieces of “in-scope” EU law a year.
“This may sound like a technical issue, but the rules in question can affect everyday matters, from food standards and consumer prices to business costs and household budgets,” he said.
“That is why effective parliamentary scrutiny is essential to ensure such changes do not pass without proper oversight.”
See also: The pros and cons for farming of closer EU alignment
The new report, called Dynamic alignment: A fundamental change, says that the value of closer alignment with the EU will affect different sectors in different ways.
“In particular, the benefits of reduced trade friction accrue principally to firms that export to the EU, whereas the obligation to follow EU rules falls on all firms in the UK.”
The report explains that the prospective SPS agreement could have very significant policy effects for the UK farming and precision breeding sectors.
“With respect to precision breeding, we note that the EU is moving in the direction of the more permissive regulatory regime established in England, but that differences remain between the two regimes,” it says.
“Immediate and complete dynamic alignment in this area would therefore curtail the regime established in England under the (Precision Breeding) Act.
“We recommend that the government seeks exemptions from dynamic alignment for precision breeding, so as to sustain the development of the industry in the UK.”
Potential dangers
The report also points to potential dangers with the recently announced Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, which already taxes fertiliser imports to the EU, but will not come into effect in the UK until next year.
The UK is planning a “soft launch”, with lower import duties on fertilisers in the first few years. This may not be allowed following realignment.
“We find it difficult to see how the UK could operate a fully autonomous Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism once it has linked its Emissions Trading Scheme with the EU’s,” says the report.
Other potential problems include plant protection products, where the UK now licences active ingredients the EU does not, and bovine TB, where the UK’s push for vaccine control could be at odds with EU rules.
Transition
Different organisations have called for transition periods of two to five years for any SPS deal.
The Lords’ report says it supports such calls, adding that “given the further passage of time since we took evidence, we are sceptical that full implementation of the SPS agreement by mid-2027 is feasible or advisable”.
It is also concerned that the future scrutiny of EU legislation by government and parliament will be hugely demanding, sapping available resource.
Food exporters warm to closer ties with Europe
A more upbeat perspective of UK:EU alignment is contained in a new Defra survey of 600 small and medium-sized food and drink manufacturers.
This shows that 55% of exporters and 47% of importers have suffered declining profits since Brexit took effect in January 2021.
Some 58% said a new UK-EU food and drink agreement could help them increase, resume or begin exporting within a year
When asked what would make the biggest difference for exporting to the EU, respondents overwhelmingly identified less paperwork (79%), lower trading costs (78%) and fewer border delays (71%).
Defra secretary Dame Angela Eagle said: “Behind every one of these figures is a family firm that should be selling great British produce abroad but is instead stuck in paperwork.
“It’s exactly why we are doing a deal with the EU, to cut red tape and ease pressure on food price inflation.”