CLA president admits he ‘feels sorry’ for Defra

The finger of blame for many of farming’s woes should be pointed at the Treasury more than at Defra, according to Country Land and Business Association (CLA) president Gavin Lane.

Addressing the CLA’s annual conference in London on Thursday (19 November), Mr Lane said Defra’s Farming Roadmap and Land Use Framework had set out a path to just limited targeted support.

See also: Defra to open £15m reservoir fund for farmers ‘soon’

“Fifty million pounds was moved out of Higher Tier and Landscape Recovery, potentially having a devastating effect, particularly in our uplands,” he said.

Meanwhile, the £15m reservoir grant scheme had been slow to emerge “presumably to find the money from another scheme”.

The recent Autumn Budget also seemed to have forgotten that “rural” existed, Mr Lane added.

“I don’t lay that at Defra’s door,” he said. “This is a Treasury problem.

“Draconian rules on the split between Defra’s capital and revenue spending were written for a calmer century, one of stable economies and open trade.

“Those days are over. We need a properly funded economic department with greater autonomy over that funding.”

The summer chaos surrounding the Sustainable Farming Incentive application process epitomised the lack of understanding at the Treasury.

“But you could design that scheme a hundred different ways and still hit the same wall,” said Mr Lane. “There is not enough money in the pot.

“When demand far outstrips the budget, farmers are left out, not by their value to the taxpayer but by where they land in the queue.”

In a Q&A session with Farmers Weekly editor Andrew Meredith, Mr Lane admitted that he actually felt sorry for Defra.

‘Growth in every postcode’

Despite the concerns, Defra secretary Dame Angela Eagle defended the government’s approach towards the rural economy, insisting it was committed to “growth in every postcode”.

She reeled off a number of strategies and schemes the government has embarked upon to deliver on that, including the Farming Roadmap and the Farming and Food Partnership Board that had been created in the wake of the Minette Batters’ Farming Profitability Review.

Dame Angela Eagle

Dame Angela Eagle © MAG/Phil Clarke

The government’s recent Budget also paved the way to allocate more tax revenue to regional authorities, with mayors given greater autonomy on how the money is spent.

“The countryside must benefit from that greater freedom – and I will ensure that it does,” she said.

But it was not all down to government to promote the rural economy and Dame Angela said the industry could and should do more to promote itself.

See more