Relief as UK-EU realignment avoids ‘cliff edge’ scenario

Fears that British farmers might face a “cliff-edge” scenario as a result of “dynamic alignment” with the EU have been quashed, following the signing of a new sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement for trade in food and drink.

After months of negotiations, details of the final SPS package emerged on Friday (20 November) following the UK-EU summit meeting in Brussels.

See also: Editor’s View – Defra diverging from EU on one key principle

While the deal will see an end to costly red tape and border inspections for a range of agri-food exports, providing a substantial boost to trade, there had been fears that it could also restrict the use of certain crop protection products in the UK.

Without a reasonable transition period for regulations to realign, CropLife UK, representing pesticide manufacturers, had predicted a £500m-£810m loss in revenue for arable farmers due to yield falls and enforced changes to cropping patterns.

Transition period

However, the deal signed off by the UK government and EU leaders on Friday make provision for a significant transition period for those pesticides that have been licenced for use in the UK since Brexit, but are not yet approved in Brussels.

The NFU has welcomed this development which will see newly approved plant protection products retained for use in the UK until such time as the EU makes its own decision on their use.

The NFU is also pleased that the SPS contains provisions to safeguard the operation of England’s Precision Breeding Act until the EU’s own framework becomes fully operational, allowing gene editing trials to continue in the UK .  

NFU president Tom Bradshaw expressed a note of caution about the boost to tfood exports the SPS deal is hoped to trigger.

“Reducing friction and costs at the border should help farm businesses that depend on access to EU markets,” he said.

“However, rebuilding lost exports will take time, as in many circumstances British products have been replaced by goods from elsewhere.

“That’s why the appointment of three new agricultural trade specialists in Europe and a further three in England to boost exports to the EU is so important and is great news.”

There were still plenty of unanswered questions, he added, for example what it would mean for bovine TB controls and for organic poultry requirements.

And the NFU pointed out that while exporters will benefit, in time realignment will have implications for those farming businesses that only serve the domestic market. 

Seed potatoes

There is good news for potato growers from the deal, who will also benefit from the provisions for plant protection products – especially that crops currently in the ground will still be exportable.

But the greatest “SPS dividend” for that sector is news that trade in seed potatoes may resume, having been blocked by Brussels for the past six years.

GB Potatoes chief executive Scott Walker said: “Today’s announcement gives us some much-needed clarity and a clearer path towards implementation on 1 March 2028.

“We are particularly pleased that the seed potato trade with the EU will resume. Before it stopped, that trade was worth around £11m a year. We hope to see it recover quickly and grow to at least that level again.”

Meat

Meat traders are also pleased that the deal has been done which should help recoup some of the loss in sales which has seen poultry exports fall by 53%, beef by 25% and lamb by 17% since 2020.

“Since Brexit, veterinary export certificates and border delays have added costs and uncertainty for British meat businesses, particularly smaller exporters,” said Dr Jason Aldiss, executive director of the Association of Independent Meat Suppliers.

However, he is less pleased about the delays to implementation of the SPS.

“The reported start date of 1 March 2028 means businesses could face another 16 months of these costs,” he said.

“We urge ministers to publish the treaty and implementation timetable promptly, remove routine export health certificates for meat covered by the agreement, and work with industry to reduce delays in the meantime.”

Lack of influence

Country Land and Business Association president Gavin Lane also had reservations.

“In the short term, there will be significant benefits to exporters but it’s naive to think that there won’t be challenges in the long term.

“When the EU comes up with a new regulation that may damage British farmers or producers, we will have no recourse. This doesn’t bode well for democracy.”

The Agriculture Industries Confederation says it is essential that the UK government is properly resourced to represent the interests of UK agriculture in Brussels, to ensure early engagement with emerging EU legislation. 

See more