Eight of nine Bradninch tenants explore buying farms

Eight of the nine farming tenants on the Duchy of Cornwall’s Bradninch estate in Devon are actively exploring buying some or all of their farms, the duchy has said.

It also says about two-thirds of residential tenants are considering buying their homes, amid growing concern about the future of an estate the duchy has owned since 1337.

The sales programme began at the 1,215ha Bradninch estate near Cullompton in March and has since expanded to parts of the Duloe Estate in Cornwall and individual holdings in Herefordshire and the Midlands. 

See also: Duchy of Cornwall reassures farmers amid estate sale concerns

The Duchy of Cornwall estate has about 700 agricultural lettings, including around 300 whole-farm holdings across 19 counties in England and Wales.

Among those voicing concern is Alistair Carmichael MP, chair of the Commons’ cross-party Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Efra) select committee, who has urged the duchy to show “sympathy and respect” to its farming tenants.

He said buying was a “genuine opportunity” for many tenant farmers. But he added: “That, however, will not be the case for everyone and we should never lose sight of the fact that this is not just about a farm business, but also usually a family home.”

Mr Carmichael warned it would be “deeply regrettable” if farming families were removed from their homes and agricultural land taken out of food production.

The Duchy of Cornwall’s figure refers to tenants exploring a purchase, not committing to one. It says buying will not suit every tenant and that it is working individually with those affected.

TFA concerns

The Tenant Farmers Association (TFA), which has consistently expressed disappointment that the duchy is selling tenanted farms, says some tenants will be unable to buy, even with discounts and flexible arrangements.

TFA chief executive George Dunn said the duchy has assured him that “nobody will be made homeless”, and he knows of no formal eviction notices.

The Duchy of Cornwall says every sitting tenant has first refusal before any wider sale, often with discounts reflecting length of tenure, type of tenancy and investment in the property.

Sales will be informed by independent valuation advice, and following talks with the TFA, all future farm sales will have a jointly instructed independent valuation. It says it is making a significant contribution to legal and professional costs where appropriate.

In a statement, the duchy said: “We recognise that these are important and deeply personal decisions.

“Every tenant is being supported through the process on a case-by-case basis, with access to practical guidance from the estate team, independent welfare and mental health support services and ongoing discussions about what is right for their circumstances.”

It says its mental health support is long-standing and not specific to this process.

Officials met all Bradninch farming tenants on 29 October and will visit again in December, with “tenant suppers” offering financial advice and mental health support planned for early 2027.

Duchy vision

HRH Prince William, as Duke of Cornwall, is selling approximately 20% of the Duchy of Cornwall’ estate over the next decade, aiming to raise more than £500m for investment in housing, local economies, renewable energy, farming resilience and nature recovery.

The duchy says proceeds from the disposal of its capital assets must be reinvested in the estate and cannot be accessed by the duke for personal distribution.