Mixed reaction as Burnham ties up EU realignment deal

Confirmation of a new sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement between the UK and EU as part of the realignment process has received a mixed reaction.

Exporters to the EU are generally pleased about the promised reductions in red tape which should boost trade. And there is relief at the carve outs for things such as plant protection products and gene editing.

But doubts remain about the lack of say the UK will have in forming future regulations, which will apply to all UK farmers regardless of whether their produce goes for export or not.

See also: Relief as UK-EU realignment avoids ‘cliff edge’ scenario

Here is a selection of industry reactions:

“The safeguard for three GB-approved active substances is welcome, but businesses need certainty about how it will operate in practice. But the UK will be applying decisions it has no vote on. It is vital that every step is taken to ensure that our voice is heard and British growers have the tools they need.”

Dave Bench, chief executive, CropLife UK

“This agreement has the potential to deliver significant benefits for Scottish agriculture, particularly by reducing trade barriers for our red meat and dairy sectors and reopening the EU market to Scottish seed potatoes. However, significant challenges remain, particularly around animal disease controls.”

Jonnie Hall, policy director, NFU Scotland 

“Stronger protections against harmful chemicals and pesticides will ease the pressure that pollution puts on UK wildlife and will boost soil health, helping to secure the healthy environment farmers need to keep producing food.”

Vicki Hird, agriculture lead, The Wildlife Trusts

“The success of this agreement will be down to its implementation and the UK government’s ability to influence future EU rules that work for Welsh farmers. Central to this will be the implementation and interpretation of EU Animal Health Law, particularly in relation to bovine TB controls and vaccination, and avian influenza.”

Abi Reader, NFU Cymru president

“It’s important for the UK to take a tougher stance on pesticides, so we welcome the news that we will align with the EU on pesticide rules. This must include glyphosate pre-harvest, or the government will have missed an opportunity to protect public health.”

Cathy Cliff, campaign co-ordinator, Soil Association

“This is a hugely welcome breakthrough for British meat businesses. For nearly six years, our industry has been battling a mountain of paperwork, unnecessary costs and border delays simply to trade with our nearest neighbours.”

John Powell, chief executive, British Meat Processors Association

“The reported start date of 1 March 2028 means businesses could face another 16 months of these costs. We urge ministers to publish the treaty and implementation timetable promptly, remove routine export health certificates for meat covered by the agreement, and work with industry to reduce delays.”

Jason Aldiss, executive director, Association of Independent Meat Suppliers

“Cutting red tape on food imports from the Continent promises to ease a source of pressure on food prices and lighten the load on shoppers.”

Rami Baitieh, chief executive, Morrisons

“We are particularly pleased that the seed potato trade with the EU will resume. Before it stopped, that trade was worth around £11m per annum. We hope to see it recover quickly and grow to at least that level again.”

Scott Walker, chief executive, GB Potatoes

“Not content with the damage they’ve already done to British farming through the vindictive family farm tax, the jobs tax, higher energy costs and ever-increasing red tape, the government now wants to sell them out to Brussels. They are forcing farmers to follow rules over which we have no say, no vote, and no veto.”

Victoria Atkins, Conservative shadow Defra secretary

See more